Petition To Oust DeKalb School Board Gains Momentum
Almost 500 people have signed an online petition thus far, including some Lakeside High students and families. Take our Patch poll and tell us if you believe DeKalb's school board should be removed.
Less than two weeks after being placed on probation, the DeKalb County School Board is now the target of an online petition calling for their removal.
CBS Atlanta is reporting that the petition has already received 490 signatures, including a Lakeside High School student who said, "I feel like I am being set up for failure by the thieving BOE."
Another Lakeside signee said, "I cannot believe the incompetence of this board can be tolerated. DeKalb County has already lost the revenue of key cities (Sandy Springs, Brookhaven, Dunwoody) because of the incompetence of DK govt. Now it is hurting our schools and childrens' future. DeKalb County Government needs to be dumped and start fresh with HONEST, COMPETENT members."
DeKalb resident Grace McKenna began the online petition, calling on Georgia Gov. Nathan Deal to replace the entire school board.
On Dec. 17, the Southern Association of Colleges & Schools (SACS) placed the school board on probation until December 2013.
"There is significant and irrefutable evidence that the DeKalb County School District is in a state of conflict and chaos,” said SACS Chairman Dr. Mark Elgart. "This failure to govern effectively has resulted in a decline in student performance, financial mismanagement, and lack of integrity and ethics in recruiting, appointing and evaluating personnel at all levels of the school system."
The Georgia Department of Education must meet within 30 days of SACS report and make a recommendation to Gov. Deal on how to proceed. Under a new law, Deal has the authority to replace the school board.
North Druid Hills-Briarcliff Patch wants to know: do you believe the governor should replace DeKalb's school board? Take our Patch poll and share your opinion in the comments section below this article.
Related Items:
DeKalb Schools Probation: 'A Lot Of Unhappiness About The Board's Leadership'
Nancy
7:31 am on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
No kids here but we do care since we own property we will need to sell in a few years!!
H.A. Hurley
8:00 am on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
Once the BEST school system in Georgia, and every professional was guided to place their children in the DCS. Years of unethical, incompetent, illegal, and poor educational services, sinking test scores...the system keeps sinking into quicksand. The current BoE and Dr. Adkinson are just a long line of people who tell the public what they think we want to hear. The schools are in deplorable conditions, parking lots full of pot holes, staff is treated unprofessionally, teachers are leaving, families are going private, or moving out of DCS. Children in poverty are left and RTTT $ is being spent on anything other than teachers and children (PhD private university tuition for 9 principals). Dr. Adkinson and the remaining BoE reps are continuing the sinking and failing practices, ie. SACS. The children, parents and residents of DC cannot continue this way. There is no urgency by Dr. Adkinson and the Board, for anything. What will it take? The longer we wait, the more $ it will cost all of us. The modern rip-off by superintendents in many school systems is to do a terrible job, and leave with a long $$ contract to be paid to them. It is costing us millions to pay for litigations, paid-out contracts, and tuition for PhDs for the highest paid administrators in DCS. DCS is unbelievably top heavy with expensive administrators. Too much nepotism, too!! Look at their admin. charts and compare to other systems. They are all feeding from the $$$$ tits of the taxpayer. Out with Dr. Adkinson!
Jo
8:43 am on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
I agree that the current board needs to go, and some drastic changes need to be made to contract policies and other operating procedures. However, it is extremely important to not just call for removal of the existing board but rather to START ORGANIZING for a better board and a better system.
Sally
8:54 am on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
Toss them out TODAY! Where is this online petition. I want to sign it. Everyday. At least once a day.
Timothy Darnell
9:21 am on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
There is a link to the online petition in the article itself, but here's the complete URL -
http://www.change.org/petitions/georgia-governor-nathan-deal-replace-the-dekalb-county-school-board-2
sally
10:06 am on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
I removed my FOUR kids from the Dekalb Co. schools years ago and enrolled them in the Catholic school system in DeKalb Co. I encourage all parents to do the same. Some way you can come up with the money to pay tuition for the cost of a great education. Think of your child's future.
Sally
9:21 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012
That's all good. But even if your children aren't in the school system it still greatly affects your property value.
Tom Doolittle
11:13 am on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
Hard to believe there are only 500 signatures. This county was ahuge factor in the Charter Commission Yes vote, primarily on the basis of this one school system's performance. I spoke with many people who said they would normally not vote for more government, but they needed an easier way to get more charter schools in operation to save DeKalb (only).
So here's your chance voters--vote again.
Tom Doolittle
11:14 am on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
OK--515 and counting...even with TV coverage? Gimme a break...should be 10,000.
Betsy Parks
11:38 am on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
There are two petitions that need to remove the DCSS board. Please sign and share! Please take 30 seconds and join us. http://www.change.org/petitions/governor-nathan-deal-and-georgia-state-board-of-education-review-sacs-findings-if-accurate-replace-the-dekalb-county-school-board
Sally
9:23 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012
Two petitions are a problem. Ya'll need to get together.
Tom L.
2:00 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
Several problems with this petition. The school board needs replacing, not banishment. If I am not mistaken, we voted in replacements who have not had a chance to make a difference. They should, at least, be allowed to represent their constituency. Another issue is the power hungry manipulative characters who have peopled the Superintendent position for at least a decade, including the present kingpin. She should also be replaced, as she represents no real change from her dishonest, selfish, and moderately racist predecessors. Finally, an issue not being addressed is the appropriate involvement of a school board as an accountability agent for the superintendent and administration. As I understand it, our board is offending SACS for overstepping its bounds (which seem to be limited legally to the hiring and firing of the superintendent). There is no accountability in the system to reign in the power of the superintendent. This needs to be addressed, as well. If power corrupts...
Betsy Parks
2:21 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
Please read the SACS report. I think it might adress some of your concerns. http://www.dekalb.k12.ga.us/www/documents/news-and-info/press-releases/SACS-report.pdf
Crash
5:40 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
I agree, Eugene Walker has to go. The petition doesn't give you the choice of choosing. I've heard good things about Nancy Jester, and I'd like to see what she can do without Walker in the way.
Tom Doolittle
5:58 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
It's true Sally--we need a Catholic school system for DeKalb County. The folks across the hwy and down Briarcliff have been great neighborhood schools. What a beautiful and dutiful environment it must be to be able to go to school there. Do you think we can petition the Diocese to build space for average and below average students too--as long as we're in the mood for petitions.
Betsy Parks
6:12 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
Tom we left Lakeside to go to Pius. It is a pleasure to send my kids to school and it should be the same in DeKalb. It can be if we remove the board and pay attention. This effort won't help my kids but its the right thing to do.
Tom L.
3:17 pm on Thursday, December 27, 2012
Betsy, thanks. Unfortunately, it condemns by association. SACS lacks the gumption to call names. I cannot believe that the references to the inappropriate actions of board members is shared equally by all members of the board. The simple truth is that they are unwilling to be direct and honest with us. Not all of the board is corrupt. I have witnessed, as a lifelong resident of DeKalb County, a product this system, and a former teacher within this system shift to a race based decision making process. We have chosen to be led by inexperienced people and people whose ineptitude has been covered by moving them into the administrative level (thinking that getting them out of the schools would protect the integrity of the system). Inept employees should be summarily dismissed and adept people should be moved into leadership positions and publicly praised regardless of race. Instead, we pad our administration with people who should fired. When was the last time the teachers have gotten a raise? Yet our superintendent garners raises and perks. This system, led by self-serving/inexperienced/incompetent administration at the highest level both in the Board and the County level administration have succeeded in delivering a near fatal blow to a once thriving education system. Go into the schools. Talk with the teachers and administrators there. For the most part you will find good, honest, experienced, and hard working employees. You will not find the same in the county offices.
Tom Doolittle
6:38 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
No doubt that it's a pleasure to go to school there, Betsy. It's a "pleasure" to go to school at any affluent school.
However, the notion that DeKalb schools can be that way is absurd. It's hard to believe I have to emphasize this, but I ask, what happens when over 50% of students qualify for assisted lunches and aren't prepared for school? Is there really any possibility that it will be a "pleasure"?
Board members don't have to be imbecils and crooks to make this a highly challenged school system--school systems in poverty are a nationwide problem--not just school systems run by fools.
.
H.A. Hurley
8:00 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
There are many children who do not qualify for free and reduced lunch, but many of those parents exited DCS. That's what happens when a system like DCS does not pay attention to its citizens, provides mediocre education, runs off good teachers, does not update infrastructure, technology and spends $$ on everything other than educating kids. Parents with options leave, children in poverty have to stay. In our neighborhood near Emory, hardly any kid goes to the neighborhood school. DCS keeps rezoning and bringing in apartments, sped classes, etc. DCS administrators have much PR work to do to speak to the community, listen and improve schools, asap. The current Board and Superintendent do not have the skills nor the intentions to turn DCS around. The $$ wasted on litigations, paid out contracts, PhDs for 9 principals, etc. is outrageous and irresponsible. DC citizens should be angry and demand better. However, most of us know how urban systems attract incompetent leaders and systems go in the toilet and kids leave. Very hard to turn around. APS has specific schools that draw kids, but the rest is terrible. Same in DCS, some schools are good, most lousy. Leadership is EVERYTHING! Cobb, FCS and Gwinnett are doing better because they respond to tax payers. DCS could care less! Waiting until all wheels fall off. With SACS, we are getting close. Out with Walker & Adkinson!! ASAP!
Crash
2:23 pm on Thursday, December 27, 2012
Many of the parents who sign up for free lunches can pay for them, but they don't because the system will pay for them.
Betsy Parks
7:13 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
We are an army family and we moved more times than I want to count. I don't think the statistics for qualifying for assisted lunches changed much from state to state but other states did a much better job. Pius is not an affluent school, we have often reference ourselves as the "little Catholic school in the hood". Are there affluent people that send there kids to school with mine? Yeah, but your missing the point. The leaders put the kids first and they waste very little if any resource. Wish DCSS was expected to do the same. Its time they were removed and we started holding them accountable as private Catholic schools and many public schools around this country do every day!
Tom Doolittle
9:54 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
You're right H.A., the faster we replace all of the people we can blame, the fewer we'll be ABLE to blame. Then it just comes down to the fact that there is nothing that can be done for a population that has been and continues to be disenfranchised socioeconomically.
It's amazing how many people who wouldn't have voted for this governor in a thousand years--and think HE"S a crook-- are asking him to come in and save their home values.
Greengirl
11:09 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012
Whatever your political persuasion, the governor is the person you appeal to whether you like him or not. When someone wins, they represent all of us, not just their voting block.
H.A. Hurley
9:20 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012
Can't believe what I am reading...can't do anything for children in poverty? USA is made up of millions of people who immigrated and got their start here, attended public schools and, typically, the next generation became more successful than the previous one. Please don't join in the DCS mentality that parents are sending us 'damaged goods' and they cannot be educated. What is wrong with people? All kids can learn and deserve an education. Teachers know what to do. If we allow them to teach and support them with materials, technology and empowerment.
Tim McGrath
10:46 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012
Good point on Gov. Deal and his ever-present 'hate' crowd. I think Gov. Deal carried Dunwoody by a large margin, though most of DeKalb may have pulled the lever for Roy Barnes.
On this issue, I'd like to imagine either man would have acted in a similar manner.
As to the socio-economic issue:
The rich get richer partially because they continue to make the same choices; conversely, the poor remain or get poorer because they continue to make the same choices.
I think that moderate DeKalb citizens are finally waking up to the travesty of DCCS, just like they did with 'The Grady's.'
Tim McGrath
10:51 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012
Mr. Hurley:
"Please don't join in the DCS mentality that parents are sending us 'damaged goods' and they cannot be educated. What is wrong with people? All kids can learn and deserve an education."
Without strong parental support, the educators job is much more difficult. That is partially why Charter Schools seem to be effective, parents are more involved.
The kids are not at fault, but without a strong family value on education, they are less likely to succeed.
Jeff Parks
12:06 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012
Tom, the principals of the Catholic School system in Dekalb can be applied throughout the county: qualified teachers and administrators, minimum overhead and bureaucracy, accountability, rigid standards and a focus on service and education. Instead we have political opportunists, profit seekers,social engineering, no standards, no authority to discipline or run their schools. Administrators who call down to parents to tell them they are not team players when they complain about inappropriate hiring or safety concerns. Those things don't happen in the area Catholic schools . Re the 50% on federal assistance, how many really need it? the schools are profiting from this program so work to get the numbers up. The disenfranchised socio economic group is a foil to maintain a corrupt system and take advantage of the group you claim is disenfranchised. The answer is not more money or promoting one group over another, it is standards and accountability for the administrators, the teachers and the students.
Tom L.
9:00 am on Sunday, December 30, 2012
Exactly. I left DCS as a teacher because my principal recommended for nonrenewal all nontenured teachers at his school. He apologized to me, saying that we wished that he could keep me but that it would not make the same statement to keep one and fire the others. He justified the decision by stating that it was a way to prove that he was making a difference in the school. The next year he returned to his old position in the administrative offices of DCS to continue his fine work. I have since been teaching in the private school sector, where parents are involved, all employees are held accountable, and excellence is an expectation, not a surprise.
Tim McGrath
6:29 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012
DeKalb School Board member, Ms. Nancy Jester states: "How ironic that I may be removed from office exactly because I discovered and made public the financial misdeeds of the third largest school district in our state," which is a very real potential outcome from Gov. Deal's review. Here is a link to Ms. Jester's complete statement:
http://whatsupwiththat.nancyjester.com/2012/12/26/my-thoughts-on-the-advanced-sacs-report/
Can you imagine the caterwauling that partial Board removals, or advancing any current member to replace Chair Walker would create? In a classic illustration of "Be careful of what you wish for," Gov. Deal may be forced to purge the entire Board to avoid a new controversy.
I am encouraged that, like Grady Hospital, the DCCS situation will benefit from the antiseptic of sunshine, public outrage, and simple sustainability of the status quo.
As to the local City school option, everyone should realize the difficulty of this legislative effort to change our State constitution. I believe the discussion of local school efforts, however well intentioned, have already served a useful purpose in highlighting public disgust, mistrust, and outrage at the School Board.
If State lawmakers take on this issue, and it passes a super-majority, we still have to figure out how to pay for plant and equipment, upfront. Maybe that sort of bond would pass in Dunwoody.
What happened in Clayton? Was the current, new Board appointed or elected?
Sally
9:29 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012
If she truly wants to make a positive change in the school board she should not complain if she get thrown out with the rest of the board. Eventually there will be new elections and she can run again. Wiping the slate clean due to public outcry would send a powerful message. It should happen. Please do not try to be like Clayton County. They elected a sheriff who is under multiple indictments. Hopefully we have not sunk that low.
Tim McGrath
10:39 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012
So, it turns out that the Clayton Board was only partially changed by Gov. Perdue's appointees, as seen here:
January 16–17, 2008: SACS CSI conducts an investigation in Clayton County, including interviews with the Schools Superintendent, each member of the Board of Education, and community members. The on-site investigation includes visits to several county schools.
February 22, 2008: Governor Sonny Perdue appoints James Bostic and William Bryant, State Board of Education members, to serve as liaisons between Clayton County and the state.
March 15, 2008: The national Accreditation Commission votes to uphold SACS' recommendation of accreditation revocation.
April 2, 2008: Clayton County School Board chairwoman Ericka Davis resigns.
July 31, 2008: Clayton County School Board submits more than 2300 pages of documents to SACS for review.
August 27, 2008: A state administrative judge recommends the removal of four board members after hearing testimony from five Clayton County residents regarding their concerns these board members.
August 28, 2008: SACS revokes Clayton County's accreditation. The same afternoon, Governor Perdue signed an executive order removing from the board[8] Michelle Strong, Lois Baines-Hunter, Yolanda Everett and Sandra Scott.
I don't think that Jester was complaining, she was pointing out the irony of being the whistle-blower, yet facing potential removal.
H.A. Hurley
10:49 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012
We have sunk that low! We have had a succession of school administrators who have cleaned out the coffers, and are asking for more. Litigations are extremely costly, wasting RTTT $ is very costly! No supporting teachers, and not educating our children is very costly. Productive citizens moving out of DC is very costly! Cities spinning off is very costly! Can we all spell GHOST TOWN? Not fixing SACS requirements will be equivalent to our own DCS Cliff! Get rid of bad people and keep good ones! We know who they are.
gdfo
11:26 am on Thursday, December 27, 2012
One link brought a page that wants me to change my Browser, why is that?
Dekalb County School board need REAL investigation or replacement.
Betsy Parks
12:38 pm on Thursday, December 27, 2012
http://dekalbschoolwatch.files.wordpress.com/2012/12/spec-review-report-for-dekalb-county-final-copy.pdf
This link works for me too. If it makes your blood boil after you read it sign the petition. http://www.change.org/petitions/governor-nathan-deal-and-georgia-state-board-of-education-review-sacs-findings-if-accurate-replace-the-dekalb-county-school-board
Tom Doolittle
1:10 pm on Thursday, December 27, 2012
This thing's finally getting around to grassroots. I just receieved a link to the petition with 630 current names via a neighborhood e-mail distributuon. My guess is we'll start seeing it takeoff. Still shocked that two area websites, Patch and Schoolwatch wouldn't have generated more signatures just on readership.
H.A. Hurley
1:51 pm on Thursday, December 27, 2012
Tim McGrath - response...
Charter schools select their kids very carefully. Long waiting lists, interviews of kids and families, detailed review of test scores and grades, discipline files, and IEPs. If SWD, you may forget it! ELL, you can forget it! Parents who don't speak English, you can forget it! Children in Poverty Ok if meet all other criteria...Free & Reduced $$, Title1 $$$ Ok, RTTT $$ Ok for charter schools. Poverty pays for charter schools. They rely on those funds from gov. Once they select their students, private schools select their kids, then the rest go to public schools. If DCS writes those kids off, and only uses the $$$ allocated for their education, then their futures look rather bleak! Remember, children do not pick their parents nor their circumstances. We as adults have a greater responsibility in public education. Please move the superintendent and Board prez out! now!
Crash
3:11 pm on Thursday, December 27, 2012
When drowning the first thing you have to do is save yourself. You can't save others if you're drowning. If the parent(s) don't care to participate in their child's education, and many don't, then their life will continue to spiral down
H.A. Hurley
6:50 pm on Thursday, December 27, 2012
This same attitude is what got us in this situation. Unethical DCS admin. Have taken advantage of parents they assumed did not know or appeared not to care. That slope often happens in urban schools. They would never think nor get away with doing it in afluent communities. Sad thing, the same people who claim to want to help kids, end up hurting thousands of kids. As a society, we have the obligation to educate all kids. Any of you have students with disabilities? Well, their services were not always available in public schools. We have a responsibility to provide services of quality. Not if we feel like it, or if their parents know their rights, or whatever unethical reasons. DCS is in quicksand, and we will all pay if we don't kick the bums out and put decent, hardworking and ethical people in. ASAP!
Crash
9:56 am on Friday, December 28, 2012
H.A. you are right. All of the public schools should educate ALL of the students. Tell me what should we do with the kids who continuously disrupt the classrooms? DeKalb County is too scared to paddle anyone anymore. In school suspension (ISS) is often a holding pen with no consequences. Parents who won't show up for parent teacher conferences will be at the school in ten minutes if they think you "disrespected" their child by making them follow the rules.
Out of school suspension puts the school at risk from losing federal dollars, too many absences and the school doesn't get paid for "educating" that student.
The schools would be in better shape if they refused federal money and its conditions.
H.A. Hurley
9:16 am on Sunday, December 30, 2012
Chronic discipline problems are major issues in most school systems. We cannot spank! ISS and OSS with parent meetings is one way. Discipline Tribunals are also being used. Alternative schools are another option. Police also arrest some students. In my experience, systems know what needs to be done, but often under-report the discipline incidents because they don't want their school to be on the 'Dangerous School' list. Those same schools often do not put necessary structure in place to prevent incidents, in the first place. Structure and discipline, without creating a 'police state' is not a strong skill many administrators have. They act only during a crisis, and chaos follows. Many middle and high schools are not monitored by security enough. Students and tchrs are not safe. Alternative schools are often under-utilized and are not providing services for kids with IEPs, not provide transportation. DCS can do much better with what is available, and expland what is needed. Disruptive students do not have the right to interrupt the learning of other students, disability or not! DCS can get knowledgable people to assist with setting up and maintaining structure in their schools. They would rather spend it in non-student related issues. DC is paying for those actions. Good people leave, bad leople stay and take over schools. Plain and simple! Are there enough good people who want change? Let's go!
H.A. Hurley
9:31 am on Sunday, December 30, 2012
TomL.
What a spineless principal you had. There are many of them who watch out for #1 only. Should have been taken to task. Sounds like he is still working for DCS. Repeating spineless acts, again and again. They are protected or they would not get a way with such unethical behaviors.
Glad you landed on your feet in a much better school. Public school systems like DCS lose many excellent teachers while protecting such marginal spineless admins. DCS is full of such stories, and that explains the poor quality of DCS. Hard to believe, but DCS used to be The Best system in GA, not too long ago. What are we waiting for? All 4 wheels are off the Cadillac, and it is sitting on blocks. We need an extreme makeover, asap!