SACS Not a Thermostat

DeKalb County Board of Education District 4 candidate Jim Kinney writes about the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools.

Southern Association of Colleges and Schools, SACS, is the organization that holds the accreditation process for DeKalb County School System.

for District 4, I am studying the rules and regulations of board membership and ethics are a particular area of interest given the recent history of the school system. Current board members have made comments, in conversation and in a campaign forum, that made me sit down hard and think about what they said:

"A school board member is not allowed to enter a school without the express permission of the superintendent."

I've been searching on the SACS website now for the rule that states that, or an explanation, or even if it exists. For an organization whose sole function is to verify that a school system is qualified to hand out diplomas, they are not very transparent. A well-written list of specifications and guidelines would be good, but all I find so far are vague statements that leave much to the discretion of the auditors.

After some thought on this, I came up with an analogy to explain my concern with the ban on school board members visiting schools.

The thermostat on my wall is used to tell the air conditioner what temperature I want the house to be. When it works properly, the air conditioner turns on and off as needed. The thermostat has a built-in thermometer that measures the air temperature, and that is how the thermostat decides it's cool enough to turn off or warm enough to turn on. If the thermometer is broken, the AC may run all the time or not at all.

The school board and its policy making authority are the thermostat. The school board passes policy to the superintendent who acts to make it happen. But here is where the "not allowed to enter" rule causes problems. Like the thermostat, the school board must have a thermometer, a progress report of sorts, to decide if the policy is effective. Currently, according to board members pointing at SACS rules, the only source for the board of this report is the superintendent.

The way it works now is the superintendent is required to implement policy and also provide the sole evaluation of their quality and effectiveness. SACS is the only other evaluator and that's only every five years.

Isn't this how we got into the mess we are in now? Lack of board oversight on a superintendent and their staff seems like the answer to "What went wrong?" Sounds like the fox guarding the hen house to me. (NOTE: I'm not accusing the current superintendent of anything. This is only about the process itself.)

OK. By now, someone is thinking, "But, Jim! The board can't micromanage all aspects of the operation of a school system?!"

And, yes, that is true, and the board should not ever consider that an option. But the board must be able to gather information about policy effectiveness that is independent of those who are being evaluated. That information comes from the teachers, principals and students. The school system has clearly shown itself to have little to no "upstream" communication process. For instance, why did for four years?

I would like to visit schools and sit down at lunch and talk with teachers and students about whatever they want to talk about. I want to be able to observe first hand – not third hand and heavily filtered and edited for "correctness" – the good, the bad and "in progress" that goes on. If we can't talk about the problems, how can we work together to create solutions?

We need a thermometer in the schools.

Sal DePasquale July 13, 2012 at 11:44 AM
My experience with SACS and SAISis that their so-called standards are applied selectively and, in my view, capriciously. Standards must be applied consistently and not subjected to political whim. I have found SACS to be contemptuous and not what their appear to be on the surface. Sal DePasquale
Tom Doolittle January 25, 2013 at 02:51 AM
SACS is criminal--here are the SAT results for DeKalb--Three schools would have made Gwinnett's top 5. Four in the top 10. Three in Cobb's Top 7. There are at least 7 that certainly with SATs that either excel or are within other schools averages. http://www.bizjournals.com/atlanta/news/2013/01/24/dekalb-county-public-high-schools.html?ana=e_du_pap&s=article_du&ed=2013-01-24 http://www.bizjournals.com/atlanta/news/2013/01/24/gwinnett-county-public-high-schools.html?ana=e_du_pap&s=article_du&ed=2013-01-24 http://www.bizjournals.com/atlanta/news/2013/01/24/cobb-county-public-high-schools-ranked.html?ana=e_du_pap&s=article_du&ed=2013-01-24 SACS would decert the WHOLE DeKalb School System and say a diploma from these schools doesn't count? People would reject buying a home in areas with these scores? Criminal and should be investigated for malfeasance and political manipulation.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »